MIX

Silvia

Lobotomies and the crazyness of it all! What are we wrong about in science?

Upon reading one of my psychology books I came across something I found that caught my attention. The book was discussing the procedure of doing a lobotomy and how they came about to instilling this procedure worldwide in psychiatric hospitals.

"A prefrontal lobotomy is a procedure where the connections in the prefrontal lobes and the rest of the brain are cut" This is straight from the book. So basically it's a surgery that severes the front of your brain (pieces are actually taken out with an instrument called the leucotome). This procedure was made on patients in the 1940's that were seen as "uncontrolable" in the psychiatric wards. Patients after the surgery had side-affects such as epilepsy, amorality (not being able to distinguish right/wrong), unresponsiveness. 40 000 patients were lobotomized in the United States before it was realized that the procedure was immoral and was doing more damage to the patients, than good.

Now here is the twist. Who thought this was a good idea and why? Lobotomies were deemed as successful based on one experiment which involved a chimpanzee. The scientist who did this experiment was Dr. Egas Moniz and he won a Nobel Prize for it. The chimpanzee prior to the experiment became upset when she made errors in a food-rewarded task. After the lobotomy, she no longer did this (possibly due to the side-affect of non-responsiveness). This sole experiment launched the beginning of it all. Today lobotimies are still being preformed in some countries. Crazy, no?

Anyways I want to know what you think about this matter? And the second question I have is what do you think we are wrong about in science today? It's something I always questioned. What is our era wrong about?

Tags: brain, lobotomy, science, structure, theories

Share

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

I don't know much about lobotomy so I can't tell why it would be considered a good idea. I'm sure the people who invented it had their reasons to think it was a good idea. It's just that those reasons were wrong. Science is a long string of corrected errors. Always has been, and always will be in my opinion. And sometimes those errors are quite big, unfortunately. And even more unfortunate is the fact that you can only call them errors in hindsight.

But that doesn't mean that we should stop everything. After all, the world in which we live in today is as it is I'd say 90% due to the progresses of science and technology. Of course, that doesn't justify doing anything you want. In the end, science is great as long as it is kept in check by ethics and morality.

Reply to This

RSS

We're a global band of kids/geeks/freaks who love art/tech/gaming/music/politics & life. Love the web. Live the FU.

Latest Activity

good going with the build man, I dunno if you carved the stuff out beforehand, but this kinda reminds me of when Queen's Brian May built his "red Special"
1 hour ago
shared the news Female Ipod and Gadget users... Memorex have de...
(via NewsShare)
3 hours ago
3 hours ago
my favorite chiptune of all time is the ibm pc (not ibm at!) version of the maniac mansion theme. my second favorite chiptune of all time is from supertux. my third favorite chiptune of all time is the usual discasting theme, followed naturally by...
4 hours ago
Some of the music are indeed chiptunes made by my friend. If I remember correctly, all of them are .IT files. I´ve been thinking about possibility put some of them at the website of Discasting, but at first I have to talk about it with the compose...
5 hours ago
shared the news One force of nature vs. another: Bill Gates tri...
(via NewsShare)
5 hours ago
Great vid there, a perfect example of a "car crash" movie :P Heard a bit of chiptune-age in there... did you get the audio from .XM files by any chance?
8 hours ago
What I was referring to, was that the way that this "could" move forward, was that people might be able to search for info about any random person through taking a photograph in the street, they don't even have to be famous. Fair enough at this p...
8 hours ago
8 hours ago
actually, zadi is the main act. and nothing against zadi- because she's the greatest video host that ever was, in my opinion. i mean she's better for tech and politics... she may still have a way to go to rank with johnny carson or even conan o'b...
12 hours ago
when i buy a smartphone it will be because i am silly loaded with money and i see one in the store running linux. i can't imagine another scenario that would result in me owning one. oh, well... you could give me one, i suppose. (just so long as ...
12 hours ago
shared the news Levi Johnston talks about Palin's resignation
(via NewsShare)
14 hours ago

Badge

© 2009   Created by Zadi

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Privacy  |  Terms of Service